Krishna Gold: Part 1 Steve Novotney August 19, 2017 10 (Writer’s Note: This is the first in a series of stories that will concentrate on the development and history of the New Vrindaban community in Marshall County.) Ridiculously Different He stumbled, and he fell, but he wanted to get the story. It was up, and up some more, and then up even another hour, and Michael Gast was a muddy and bit of bloody mess when he finally found what he was looking for back in 1968. His discovery, though, was the very, very beginning of what is now New Vrindaban and the Palace of Gold. Those robe-wearing, shaved-heads-with-a-pony-tail people encountered by Gast were in their early 20’s and hoping to acquire a marriage license so they could wed on land they considered sacred. He was 21 years old and a third-year intern in the summer of 1968 for one of the Wheeling newspapers, and had worked his way through the obituary and police-beat duties so he could be assigned a “beat” and operate as a real reporter. That “beat” was Marshall County, all 312 square miles of it and not only Moundsville and Glen Dale and Cameron. The county at the time was attracting new residents because of the manufacturing and industrial jobs along the shores of the Ohio River, but diverse it was not, and that is why the Hare Krishna couple attracted Gast’s attention. “I was an intern reporter for the local newspapers in Wheeling back in 1968, but my beat was Marshall County,” Gast explained. “So, I would visit the Marshall County Courthouse pretty often, and there are a lot of different departments in that one building, so I was usually able to find something to write about. One day I walked into the Marshall County Clerk’s Office, and there were these two people wearing those robes, and they had shaved heads. The hike Gast made from Moundsville to the Hare Krishna encampment near Limestone took more than four hours to complete. (Google Maps) “I was trying to overhear their conversation because, well, that was my job and then finally I said to them, ‘You look pretty unusual for this area,’ and they said, ‘Oh, we know. We are Hare Krishnas,’” he said. “I knew them from the airports because they were at those kinds of places in the late 1960s, but the last place I ever thought I would see them was in Marshall County.” But there they were, and Gast immediately became determined to reveal them to a region that was mostly Caucasian, Catholic, and cautious of everything and anyone different. “I asked them if I could speak with them so I could do a story on them for the newspaper, and they said they loved the idea, and they invited me to follow them to where they were living at that time,” Gast recalled. “Now, they did tell me it was a four-hour hike in the woods, so I had to check at the office because I was on a deadline. The city editor at the time didn’t like me, so I doubt he cared if I got killed, but he approved it, and the Krishnas told me what to look for on the way up the hill. “I climbed way up that hill using the landmarks, and by the time I finally found where they were it was late afternoon,” he said. “And when I did get up there, I see that they are living out of Army surplus tents, drinking fresh milk, and eating oranges. They offered me a seat on a pile of dirt, and when I looked around, I saw that some of the women were holding babies. I didn’t like that at all because of the crude conditions at their encampment.” The International Society of Krishna Consciousness (ISKON) was founded in 1968 in New York City by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada. (Google Images) A Cub’s Hunger The International Society of Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) was founded in 1968 in New York City by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, a man still worshiped by members of the movement. So, why were these followers here in Marshall County, a place night-and-day different from the most populated city in the United States? “That’s the story I wanted to tell, and I really wanted that story. For that part of the world to choose Marshall County? That was a big story,” Gast said. “They were like aliens from another planet. Aliens in Marshall County? Knowing the little that I knew at that time about the newspaper business, I was pretty sure that the story I wrote would be read by everyone who bought the newspaper. “After I finally found them, I saw that it was a very rudimentary beginning and that it looked like a refugee camp. At that point, they had not even thought of building all of the temples on all of the hilltops, or having a live elephant on the property like they used to. They had been there three weeks when I visited,” he remembered. “When I asked them what they were going to do for money, they told me that they beg, and that’s what they do. When I went back after I moved home a couple of years ago, I tried to imagine where the spot was where that meeting took place, but so much has changed in the last 50 years that it was impossible.” Gast, though, did not get to hear the story of Prabhupada’s ISKCON invention or what was planned for the Marshall County land. No one spoke of the temples, the tourism, or the temptation that would consume the community during the years to follow. They wanted him. “As soon as I sat down I asked them about who they are, what they are, and why they were here, and they told me that this was a sacred place and that’s why they were there,” Gast reported. “After I asked them to tell me more, they told me that they wanted me to stay. I told that I had to get back to the office, but they continued to say that they wanted me to stay forever. That’s when I got a little scared. “I reminded them that I was a news reporter and that my bosses knew where I was, and I repeated that I had to get back, and that’s when one of them said to me that the story only becomes a story if I would become one of them,” he explained. “They were very hospitable until it all got very weird, so I told them thank you, and that’s when I went to walk away.” There are several statues of Swami Prabhupada, who passed away in 1977 at the age of 82. (Google Images) It freaked him out. One of the men grabbed his arm, twice, after he had surrendered his assignment and taken steps toward the path back because he failed to believe he possessed an aura about him as they suggested. They were Americans, and one of them, Gast believes, could have been Keith Ham, or, Swami Bhaktipada, the man who came to be the so-called spiritual leader of a village who ultimately tarnished all that gold. “Instead of answering any of my questions, they were being aggressive with the recruiting, so I became convinced they had an idea of what they would do with me if I decided to stay. I don’t know what that may have been, but that’s what I believe,” he said. “In the years that have passed, I have done research on the Hare Krishna consciousness, and I know that it’s a religious spiritual pursuit for many, many people, but it was different in 1968. No one here was ready for that when they arrived; I know that for sure. “I did get something when I asked why they decided to do whatever they had planned here, and they replied, ‘Why not?’ And that’s when I knew that every question I would ask would be turned into a puzzle. I told them that if they didn’t give me any more information that this wouldn’t be much of a story,” Gast said. “I kept asking for more information, and they kept saying that I needed to stay there if I wanted to learn more.” It was the 1960s, a decade that began with a president who handled the Cold War well before he was assassinated in Dallas, and ended with the country embroiled in combat in Vietnam with thousands of draftees nearly 9,000 miles away. It was a period of time in America, Gast uttered, when no one knew what to expect next. “It was when most people were afraid of the weird and unusual because of what they seeing on their televisions during the nightly news. And, yeah, the people I visited were beyond the standard of the unusual and weird. And they were aggressive, at least with me,” he said. “I can’t tell you how many times they told me that I was meant to stay there. I had to tell them that I was leaving more than once. “I was polite about it, but I did have to be pretty assertive about it, and then they let me go. At least that’s how I felt at the time,” Gast continued. “I was chasing a story that I thought be a big story, and I got no story, really. It was still a big story, but it wasn’t mine.” The gold is 22-karat leaf paint that is used on most of the temples at ISKON communities. (Google Images) Beat on the Beat It was close to hour during his hike up the hill to the Hare Krishna members when he second-guessed himself about setting off on such a journey, but on his way back down, using the same downed trees, small streams, deep hollows, rock formations, and buttocks-dragging declines, Gast felt lucky, and he felt anxious. “There was a point in time when I did believe they were going to kidnap me because when I initially tried to leave, one of the men grabbed my arm,” Gast said. “Eventually, though, they let me go, and that’s when I set on the long walk back to a place somewhere in Moundsville. “What I remember the most about walking out of there was that it was straight down. It was a big climb, but by the time I decided to head back down, I guess I didn’t realize just how much I did climb, and the whole time I kept thinking that as long as I was heading down, I would end up somewhere in Moundsville,” Gast said. “At least, that’s what I hoped.” Sweaty, muddy, tired and torn, Gast finally reached his vehicle as day was fading into nighttime. He navigated the 12 miles north along WV2 back to the Wheeling office on Main Street, sat down at his desk, and tapped out what he could about his expedition to the infancy of a Krishna community that would soon attract national attention as an attraction and as an atrocity. “I wrote the story that I had, and then I got some pretty bad news” Gast remembered. “That’s when I found out, just the day before, Susan Schubert got the story. She went there with a photographer, saw the same things I did, but had a very different conversation than what I had with the group. Devotees have frequented public places such as airports for many years. (Google Images) “Susan and I were both students at Bethany; she worked for one paper and I worked for the other because they really competed back in those days, and her story was an excellent story. She and the photographer made that same hike, and her story had more depth than mine because they didn’t try to recruit those two,” he said. “They didn’t try to recruit Susan because, I believe, she was with a man who had like five cameras with him, so they told her that their goal was to establish a North American center for the Hare Krishna belief.” Gast, then and now, has never assigned himself a denomination when it comes to Christianity because he doesn’t believe in beliefs, yet he has long been convinced there exists a higher power. Whether the Jews, Catholics, Episcopalians or Krishnas have religion right did not concern Gast when he set out on a journey he’d never forget. “I thought the story would be something about something that no one in this valley would know anything about, but that they would interested in it because of how different they were from the vast majority of the people in this valley,” Gast said. “So, I am sure there would have a lot of interest in the story, and I am sure the people would want more and more information about what was going on. “The first land purchase the Krishnas made wasn’t huge parcel, but it allowed them to start whatever it was they had planned, and since there has been a lot news about that community that we have learned because of the trials and the experiences that people have had. But I will never forget that experience meeting the very first group of people that laid claim to what it is today.” ISKCON communities are located throughout the world and each of them possess elaborate temples just as New Vrindaban in Marshall County does. (Google Images) Cops & Krishnas Once the story was published, the Krishna community was on law enforcement’s radar, not because crimes were being committed but because no one knew what to expect. What John Gruzinksas knew when he arrived in Marshall County in 1978 to accept a position with the West Virginia State Police was that the movement’s leader, Swami Prabhupada, had passed away the year before at the age of 82, and no plan was in place for another devotee to assume the position. “New Vrindaban was one of the first places the veterans of the State Police in Moundsville took me because they needed to get me familiar with what was going on up there,” he explained. “So, we got into the cruiser, and we went out to see the Krishnas, and at that point they only had constructed a few buildings. They had the original farm, which is still standing, and that was the place we visited first. “It was close to lunchtime, and I saw a long line of residents that were there to get lunch, and what it reminded me of immediately was something like the photos I’d seen of a concentration camp because there were these loud speakers blaring these chants,” Gruzinksas recalled. “And, at that time, the other troopers told me that they were on a very strict diet so they would be able to do what the leaders needed them to do so the community continued to grow.” That very first visit took place soon after the community had been quarantined because of a hepatitis outbreak, prompting officials with the Marshall County Health Department to treat several hundred residents. “They told me that every single member of the community had to be inoculated,” Gruzinksas said. “And there were some things that took place up there that were common practice like the tremendous infant mortality rate that they had. “They handled all of the births themselves with midwives, and I have no idea if they had any training whatsoever, but there were many times when the utility companies would be working on their land, and they would unearth caskets with children in them,” he continued. “That happened a lot because the members would bury them wherever they wanted. They weren’t marked or anything. Those children were just buried.” Keith Ham, or Kirtanananda Swami, was the co-founder of New Vrindaban and was the community’s leader for nearly 30 years. (Google Images) Although Gast and Schubert were not told of a Palace of Gold during their respective interviews, such a shrine was under construction and set to open to the public two years later. Built with elaborate materials from 17 countries and more than 8,000 square feet of 22 karat gold leaf trim, the palace was initially meant to serve as a residence for Swami Prabhupada. With their leader dead, though, the devotees altered the plan to involve tourism. “The people building the palace were the residents and not employees with construction companies or anyone like that,” Gruzinksas explained. “And, when I first arrived in Moundsville, the one question no one could answer for me was where the Krishnas’ money was coming from to build such a large structure and paint it with real gold paint. No one knew much about anything even though the devotees had been on that property for a decade. “I really didn’t believe they could finance such a project by just going to the airports and doing what they did there,” he said. “So that was a red flag for me from the very beginning.” What Gruzinksas, who served eight years as sheriff before being elected last year to the Marshall County Commission, did figure out was how Prabhupada’s disciples were able to purchase a large parcel of land in Marshall County. “There were only a few of them in the very beginning, and I was told that one of the first places they went was Richard Rose’s farm, and they stayed with him. Richard was a self-proclaimed philosopher, and he had self-published several books about philosophy,” the retired trooper explained. “He was one interesting cat to talk to, and he welcomed about a half dozen of the Krishnas. “After the members traveled back and forth between New Vrindaban and their operation in New York, they brokered a deal to lease the property up there for 99 years for a token amount,” he reported. “Richard thought he knew what he was getting into, but he really didn’t, and although he argued against the deal, the Krishnas had a pretty iron-clad contract. He was stuck.” But his wonderment about the community’s growth and revenue generation bothered Gruzinksas, and another fact with which he was concerned was that the New Vrindaban community was cared for medically by a “doctor” who was not a trained physician. So, the trooper did what troopers do. “During that investigation one of the people I spoke with was an official with the state’s medical association in Charleston, and when I asked what they had done to supervise the medical practice at New Vrindaban, I was told that they were just allowing them to do whatever it was they were doing back then,” Gruzinksas said. “After I asked why they were looking the other way, I was told that they did that because they did not know who else would treat the sick in that community. “It just seemed like no one cared,” he said. “The only thing I knew about the Hare Krishnas was what I would see when I was at an airport, but what I saw during that first visit was very eye opening. It was the last thing I expected to find in Marshall County, W.Va. A huge temple in the middle of nowhere. Yup, that was a pretty big surprise.” Share this:Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window) 10 Responses vince September 14, 2017 Where in the hell was Mr. Gast that he could hike through the woods to get to the compound. There is a road form Limestone that leads very close to where the Krishna community started. Log in to Reply Yam Rutesellar August 23, 2017 It was one of the very first invitations from N.V. to the community to come up and meet and greet. The temple was recently “completed” (if it ever is finished). Our family, my brother and I in our late 20’s, mom as open-minded as they come and dad the quintessential WWII vet conservative all decided to check it out. It took some persuading for the old man but he relented probably to “protect” us! We had a great time. My father’s suspicious nature was quickly disarmed when we entered the grounds. The devotees were very friendly and welcoming, the architecture and gardens, flowers..artwork was breathtaking. Dad, as were all of us, were very impressed. Still, he warned us that he absolutely refused to eat any of the food offered there……until his sweet tooth saw the scrumptious pastries they were selling. All bets were off now as he dove into those honey, walnut and flaky baked goods..with a sack to take home. It was a long standing family joke that the old man entered as a grudging contrarian and he almost became a devotee over the sweets. Log in to Reply Jason August 22, 2017 Gast claims to have been familiar with devotees in airports prior to seeing them in Wheeling in 1968. Mass book distribution (including at airports), didn’t begin until the early 70s. A caption says ISKCON was formed in 1968. That took place in 1966. It refers to the Palace of Gold opening in 1970. Construction began in 1972 and it opened in 1979. (see http://palaceofgold.com/history.html). Log in to Reply Michael J. Iafrate August 21, 2017 Very disappointed that Weelunk published this piece, but not surprised given the source. I’ve heard from devotee friends that later installments will be “more positive” in describing the New Vrindaban community. That’s wonderful, but one would think that a “series of stories that will concentrate on the development and history of the New Vrindaban community in Marshall County” would start with a positive depiction of this religious community’s founding and beliefs based on interviews with folks who have lived there since the beginning. (They’re around.) Instead, the author gave zero indication that he wanted to write anything remotely balanced or sympathetic or anything beyond the usual Wheeling mob pieces that he tends to write. His first interviewees were not devotees but a cop and another journalist. The photos he posted are from Google, not from New Vrindaban. One of the first headings in the article describes devotees and “ridiculously different” and the article goes on to give voice primarily to people who call devotees “aliens” rather than to devotees themselves. And the first version of this story even misspelled New Vrindaban — the very subject of the story — repeatedly. (They corrected it, though without acknowledgment or apology.) It’s sort of like if Weelunk wanted to run a “series of stories that will concentrate on the development and history of the Roman Catholic Church in the Ohio Valley” and started by interviewing cops and lawyers about Father So-and-so who raped children. Of course terrible things happened at New Vrindaban. There are many places to go to read about it. (This story seems to get some of it right and some of it wrong.) But the story of NV under Bhaktipad is only one part of the story. A publication ostensibly dedicated to “changing the story” about Wheeling and about West Virginia should do better than this “Monkey on a Stick” wannabe article. As a participant in a deeply ambiguous religious tradition (Roman Catholic), and as a scholar of these traditions, I believe it is important that believers are honest about the positive and negative aspects of our traditions. But in a time when religious literacy is lacking and interreligious understanding is vitally important, to publish a piece that frames the story as a whole in this way is irresponsible and dangerous. Serious misfire, Weelunk. I’m looking forward to reading further installments, hoping that you accept the invitation to speak with a variety of devotee voices, and that part two will demonstrate religious literacy, truthfulness, and respect rather than just a cheap, gold encrusted version of Wheeling’s mob story. Hare Krsna! Log in to Reply Thierry Phillips August 21, 2017 Steve, I’ve known you for years. I’m very curious why you lead with Gast’s detailed subjective reactions, and no others from anyone else (such as Susan Schubert and her photographer, who GOT their story published first), and a raft of subjective observations from John Gruzinskas, who over the years has acquired a huge number of facts about the community and its members- I guess facts don’t serve your narrative anywhere near as well as sinister suggestion and innuendo. This is fare for a book perhaps, like “Monkey On A Stick”, not “newsy” in anything but the sense of a hatchet-job. Did people do bad stuff to other people in New Vrindaban over the years? Being human, that’s a deafening “YES”, exactly the same in Wheeling, Moundsville, and EVERY other community, including EVERY other religious community in the county, state, and the rest of the world. One thing you COULD have mentioned early on in the article to render more appropriate perspective on the basic story than only Mr Gast’s and Mr. Gruzinska’s personal reactions, is that New Vrindaban is a place of religious pilgrimage for HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS of people around the entire world. Don’t just take my word for it, query any Vaisnava (or nearly all other denomination) Hindu. It may not have started that way in 1967, but it was already Srila Prabhupada’s very strong desire (couched in VERY explicit instructions to his disciples there and everywhere else) just a few years later. I’ll be interested to read whether your future installments represents all, most, or even ANY of the good things that devotees in New Vrindaban HAVE done in the past 50 years, with the end result of a huge amount of conscientious work, the annual Festival of Colors (Holi) and with the second this year, now an annual event, Rathyatra, being enormously popular events locally along with drawing many people to the Ohio Valley from great distances who very likely would have little or no OTHER motivation to visit this area. Log in to Reply Thierry Phillips August 21, 2017 It was an ad in the East Village Other by Richard Rose that started it all, Jim. Log in to Reply Thierry Phillips August 21, 2017 You should save your attack journalism for current events, Steve- it can do some good there. In the case of events two or more generations old, it’s only value is fictive, for suspense. Log in to Reply Molly August 19, 2017 I haven’t read thrhough this whole article yet. I’m hoping that it is not the same negative narrative that the New Vrindaban Community has been moving away from for many years now. I’ll point out right away that you’ve misspelled New Vrindaban (it is t Vrindavin) and Iskcon, not Iskon. Who edited this story? Log in to Reply Jim Coster August 19, 2017 i grew up in Marshall County. i lived in McMechen as a baby, then on a farm on Fork Ridge, then for a time in Moundsville, and finally in Glen Dale. i was in the valley from 1954 to 1978. my family was involved with law enforcement and a lot of social organizations during that time. i was personally involved in Marshall County politics from 1970 to 1978. i know quite a bit about “the Krishnas” and “New Vrindabin.” i will be interested in reading (and checking the accuracy of) further articles about this very odd and “unique” group who seemingly “just fell out of the sky one day” to alight on Marshall County, West Virginia. Log in to Reply Diana Williams August 18, 2017 When I was there in 69 or 70, there was a just a small group of people living in the farm house….no tents, no robes…..just hippie-type people in a communal setting. They gave us fresh goat milk and we just talked. Keith Ham was still just Keith Ham then and was purchasing the land from Richard Rose. Who’d have guessed, back then?…… Log in to Reply Leave a Reply Cancel ReplyYou must be logged in to post a comment.